Now, this is only about their writing. Not their personality, their interviews, their appearance, nada. Plain and simple: We're judging based off the episodes they've written.
I'm only including writers who have five or more writing credits on the show. You won't need to be familiar with who wrote what. It's all listed for you on the poll. :)
Okay! Let's get poll-y!
All of the episodes Joss wrote are listed below. Check your Top 3. Only choose THREE! I'm watching you!
Marti Noxon's turn. Again, Top 3. Three! Only choose three!
And another round for Jane Espenson, fan favorite. Top 3, folks!
David Fury! He got the mustard out. Pick only three! Don't make me spank you!
Douglas Petrie: Wore the same shirt as Riley once. Three's the magic number. Have at it!
Now time for David Greenwalt! 1, 2, 3, GO!
Rebecca Rand Kirshner! She looks like Cassie from Help! Top 3!
Moving on to Drew Z. Greenberg. Pick three.
Dean Batali & Rob Des Hotel seem to come as a pair? They share credits for the exact same episodes, so we'll count them together. Top 3!
Steven S. DeKnight now!
Are you ready for this? We're gonna go through it again. This time, though, choose the Bottom 3! This one's for Joss. Three worst episodes. Go!
Bottom three for Marti! Only three!
And the Bottom 3 for Jane Espenson!
Mr. David Fury, it's time to meet your Bottom 3!
Back to Doug Petrie. Weakest three.
Bottom three for David Greenwalt!
And finally, bottom three for Rebecca Rand Kirshner:
Wrapping things up, your favorite writer?
Okay, your favorite writer besides Joss? (If you didn't choose Joss in the previous question, just repeat your answer here)